Sir Carl is a paladin who is located in the Underground Pass . He is defeated by players during the Underground Pass quest in order to collect the green Paladin's badge . He can be fought again after the quest is complete.
The following drop rates are provided by Jagex, unless otherwise specified.
The average Sir Carl kill is worth 348 coins .
^ Only dropped if not already in the player's backpack.
There is an 8/128 chance of rolling the herb drop table .
There is a 2/128 chance of rolling the gem drop table .
Gem and rare drop table
^ 50 coins replaces members-only drops in free-to-play.
^ Molten glass removed from the drop table with tier 2 luck .
^ Runite stone spirit removed from the drop table with tier 3 luck .
^ Raw lobster removed from the drop table with tier 4 luck .
^ Vecna skull requires tier 4 luck . Without it, coins are dropped instead.
^ Cheese+tom batta dropped only without tier 4 luck . Indicates a roll for Hazelmere's signet ring and Blurberry Special.
^ Blurberry Special requires tier 4 luck . Indicates a failed 1/10 roll for Hazelmere's signet ring.
^ Hazelmere's signet ring requires tier 4 luck .
^ Only when wearing the Asylum doctor's ring .
^ Only obtainable if a court summons is not already owned or if all Court Cases have been completed. For every monster that drops court summons killed after 200 kills, the denominator decreases by 1 for every kill until the item is guaranteed at 399 kills.
Transcripts Sir Carl speaks in:
This information has been compiled as part of the update history project . Some updates may not be included – see here for how to help out!
update 2 March 2026 (Update ):
Default base hit chances increased:
Magic ('weak'): 65 → 70
Melee ('same'): 55 → 60
Ranged ('strong'): 45 → 50
patch 15 December 2025 (Update ):
All 'Talk-to' options across the game have been replaced with 'Talk to'.
Some consider his name to be a play on words. If said correctly, it sounds like 'Circle'. This is also common with white knights .
If you try to talk to him after completing the Underground Pass quest, he will recognise you and exclaim, "You again... die Zamorakian scum!"