The argumentative man was a man located in Edgeville and was directly situated in front of the Edgeville General store. He was altercating with his brother upon the subject of which god they would side with in the Battle of Lumbridge. Although he has a brother, there was a disparity in their facial features, the argumentative man having a longer, more prominent nose and thinner eyes.
The argumentative man's attire consisted of a short grey shirt, grey shorts and sandals.
This article on an NPC has an associated transcript page. Click here for a transcript of possible conversations and other messaging related to this NPC.