A Terrible pie (uncooked) is an uncooked Terrible pie. It is made by using the manky crayfish and the stinking potato on the maggoty pie shell. It is used in the Let Them Eat Pie quest.
If you try to cook the pie on a fire, you will get the message "While no doubt history will remember you kindly if you consign this abomination to the cleansing flames and walk away, you need it to poison Rolo. Try cooking it on a range or oven instead."
This information has been compiled as part of the update history project. Some updates may not be included - see here for how to help out!