Talk:Shiny columbarium key

From the RuneScape Wiki, the wiki for all things RuneScape
Jump to: navigation, search
This talk page is for discussing the Shiny columbarium key page.

Drops[edit source]

223 openings

Item                Quantity dropped      quantity total

Herb

toadflax             2 Noted                14
avantoe             2 noted                22
kwarm                 2 noted                30
snapdragon            2 noted                12
lantadyme            2 noted                8
dawrfweed             2 noted                20
torstol                2 noted                38

Seed

dwarf weed            1                9
Lantadyme             1                8
Snape grass             8                48
Watermelon            8                128

Tertiary

Red Spider Eggs         8 noted                64
Limpwurt Root             8 noted                64

ore/gems/bars

Addy Ore             8 noted                64
Rune Bar             1 noted                5
Uncut Ruby             4 noted                44
Uncut Diamond             4 noted                36

Gear

rune spear            1 noted                4
Rune pickaxe             1 noted                6
Rune Arrows            50                550
rune plate legs            1 noted                9
rune helm            1 noted                8
addy plate (t)            1                1
dragon spear            1                1
saradomin kiteshield        1                1

runes

blood                20                240

Charms

gold                1                13
green                1                10
red                1                9
blue                1                12

Other

Loop half of Key        1 noted                5
tooth half of key        1 noted                5

 —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 88.159.70.8 (talk) on 17:34, July 20, 2015‎ (UTC).

Drops[edit source]

26 Keys 

1. 8 Watermelon seeds
2. 2 Grimy toadflax
3. 2 Grimy torstol
4. Lantadyme seed, Crimson charm
5. Loop of key
6. 8 Snape grass seed
7. 2 Grimy torstol, Gold charm
8. Lantadyme seed
9. 4 Uncut ruby
10. 8 Red spiders' eggs
11. 2 Grimy avantoe
12. 2 Grimy avantoe
13. Rune pickaxe
14. Rune helm
15. 8 Adamantite ore
16. 4 Uncut diamond
17. Dwarf weed seed
18. 4 Uncut ruby
19. 2 Grimy torstol
20. 4 Uncut ruby
21. 8 Watermelon seeds
22. Rune pickaxe, Crimson charm
23. 8 Red spiders' eggs
24. 2 Grimy avantoe
25. 20 Blood runes
26. Rune helm

BGUyLfN.png CJaW7Er.png 18:10, July 23, 2015 (UTC)

Is there any difference in the chances of this key appearing instead of the normal key when using Magic Pyre logs versus using Elder Pyre logs? 
Chenw (talk) 00:17, July 24, 2015 (UTC)
The shiny key is always guaranteed whenever you use magic or elder pyre logs.
P.S. Indent your replies with colons (amount depends on the level of comment). It increases readability for others. BGUyLfN.png CJaW7Er.png 00:54, July 24, 2015 (UTC)

Loot log[edit source]

295 openings

Item - Quantity - Total

Armor/Weapons

Rune Spear - 1 - 6 Rune Helm - 1 - 11 Rune Pick - 1 - 8 Rune Legs - 1 - 12 Dragon Spear - 1 - 4

Herbs

Grimy Kwuarm - 2 - 38 Grimy Avantoe - 2 - 24 Grimy Lant - 2 - 28 Grimy Snap - 2 - 12 Grimy Dwarf Weed - 2 - 30 Grimy Toadflax - 2 - 14

Tertiary

Red Spider Eggs - 8 - 112 Limpwurt - 8 - 72

Seeds

Lant - 1 - 5 Dwarf Weed - 1 - 7 Snape Grass - 8 - 144 Watermelon - 8 - 120

Charms

Gold - 1 - 24 Green - 1 - 17 Crimson - 1 - 12 Blue - 1 - 15

Misc

Rune Bar - 1 - 11 Adamantite ore - 2 - 112 Uncut Ruby - 4 - 72 Uncut Diamond - 4 - 48 Loop Half Key - 1 - 7 Tooth Half Key - 1 - 11 Guthix Page 1 - 1 - 1 Zamorak Page 3 - 1 - 1 Rune Arrow - 50 - 900 Blood Rune - 20 - 240

Notes: While wearing ring of Wealth

lDemonlTalk .:. 02:00, September 17, 2015 (UTC)

109 keys[edit source]

  1. 2 grimy kwuarm
  2. 4 uncut ruby
  3. 8 addy ore
  4. 8 limpwort root
  5. 8 limpwort root
  6. 2 grimy lantadyme
  7. 2 grimy lantadyme + 1 crimson charm
  8. 2 grimy avantoe
  9. 1 dwarf weed seed
  10. 20 blood rune + 1 gold charm
  11. 8 watermelon seed
  12. 50 rune arrow
  13. 1 loop half key
  14. 2 grimy kwuarm
  15. 1 rune helm
  16. 8 addy ore
  17. 1 tooth half key
  18. 2 grimy lantadyme
  19. 1 rune bar
  20. 2 grimy torstol + 1 blue charm
  21. 2 grimy snapdragon
  22. 8 red spider eggs
  23. 8 red spider eggs + 1 blue charm
  24. 8 red spider eggs
  25. 1 rune pickaxe + 1 crimson charm
  26. 50 rune arrow
  27. 2 grimy torstol
  28. 2 grimy toadflax
  29. 1 loop half key
  30. 1 dwarf weed seed
  31. 1 lantadyme seed + 1 blue charm
  32. 2 grimy kwuarm + 1 crimson charm
  33. 2 grimy snapdragon + 1 blue charm
  34. 8 limpwurt root
  35. 4 uncut diamond
  36. 8 red spiders' eggs
  37. 2 grimy avantoe
  38. 1 rune legs
  39. 20 blood rune + 1 crimson charm
  40. 2 grimy toadflax
  41. 8 red spiders' eggs
  42. 1 rune pick + 1 blue charm
  43. 2 grimy torstol
  44. 8 snape grass seed
  45. 2 grimy toadflax
  46. 1 rune spear
  47. 1 dwarf weed seed
  48. 1 loop half key
  49. 2 grimy toadflax + 1 gold charm
  50. 1 dragon spear
  51. 50 rune arrow
  52. 1 lantadyme seed
  53. 2 grimy avantoe
  54. 1 rune spear
  55. 50 rune arrow
  56. 20 blood rune
  57. 4 uncut ruby
  58. 1 rune pick
  59. 1 rune bar + 1 gold charm
  60. 8 red spiders' eggs
  61. 1 rune helm
  62. 2 grimy snapdragon
  63. 8 watermelon seed
  64. 4 uncut diamond
  65. 2 grimy snapdragon
  66. 8 snape grass seed + 1 gold charm
  67. 1 lantadyme seed
  68. 2 grimy snapdragon
  69. 8 limpwurt root
  70. 1 loop half key
  71. 8 watermelon seed
  72. 8 watermelon seed + 1 gold charm
  73. 8 snape grass seed + 1 gold charm
  74. 8 watermelon seed
  75. 8 red spiders' eggs
  76. 1 rune helm
  77. 4 uncut diamond
  78. 4 uncut diamond + 1 green charm
  79. 1 rune spear
  80. 2 grimy lantadyme
  81. 2 grimy dwarf weed
  82. 4 uncut ruby
  83. 50 rune arrow + 1 green charm
  84. 2 grimy lantadyme
  85. 2 grimy toadflax
  86. 2 grimy lantadyme
  87. 2 grimy lantadyme + 1 gold charm
  88. 8 red spiders' eggs
  89. 1 zamorak page 3
  90. 1 rune helm
  91. 50 rune arrows
  92. 2 grimy kwuarm + 1 gold charm
  93. 2 grimy toadflax
  94. 2 grimy avantoe
  95. 2 grimy toadflax
  96. 2 grimy toadflax
  97. 1 rune helm
  98. 4 uncut diamond + 1 green charm
  99. 2 grimy dwarf weed + 1 crimson charm
  100. 4 uncut diamond
  101. 20 blood rune
  102. 2 grimy kwuarm
  103. 1 rune bar
  104. 1 rune pick + 1 green charm
  105. 2 grimy toadflax
  106. 8 limpwurt root
  107. 4 uncut diamond
  108. 2 grimy snapdragon + 1 green charm
  109. 8 watermelon seed + 1 crimson charm

71.71.102.10 03:02, February 1, 2016 (UTC)

540 Keys[edit source]

Item Total Percentage (%)
Gold charm 36 6.667
Green charm 27 5.000
Crimson charm 26 4.815
Blue charm 23 4.259
Zamorak platebody 1 0.185
Rune helm 13 2.407
Rune platelegs 15 2.778
Rune spear 20 3.704
Rune pickaxe 16 2.963
Rune arrow (50) 32 5.926
Black kiteshield (t) 1 0.185
Dragon spear 4 0.741
Grimy toadflax (2) 14 2.593
Grimy avantoe (2) 30 5.556
Grimy kwuarm (2) 26 4.815
Grimy snapdragon (2) 15 2.778
Grimy lantadyme (2) 15 2.778
Grimy dwarf weed (2) 25 4.630
Grimy torstol (2) 19 3.519
Watermelon seed (8) 34 6.296
Snape grass seed (8) 25 4.630
Lantadyme seed 15 2.778
Dwarf weed seed 15 2.778
Blood rune (20) 29 5.370
Adamantite ore (8) 24 4.444
Rune bar 16 2.963
Uncut ruby (4) 31 5.741
Uncut diamond (4) 28 5.185
Red spiders' eggs (8) 25 4.630
Limpwurt root (8) 19 3.519
Loop half of a key 16 2.963
Tooth half of a key 17 3.418

Used this data along with some reasonable extrapolation (aka if it drops one black (t) item, it can drop all of the set) to update the drop tables. A drop rate of ~4.5% or higher was considered common. Removed the {{Incomplete}} template for now because I think it is more or less updated, though I personally cannot speak on the god pages presently being a possible drop.  Panjy16 ★ 21:00, November 3, 2016 (UTC)


100 Keys[edit source]

1 Saradomin pg 1
5 rune helmets
16 gold charms
1 red charm
5 green charm
5 blue charms
16 snape grass seeds
4 tooth half of key
1 loop half of key
4 grimy kwuarm
40 watermelon seeds
5 dwarf weed seeds
48 adamant ore
1 dragon spear
12 grimy torstol
14 rubies
6 grimy avantoe
2 rune platelegs
450 rune arrows
24 diamonds
48 limp roots
4 grimy toadflax
16 red spider eggs
4 rune spear
3 rune pickaxe
3 rune bars
60 blood runes
4 grimy snaps
1 lantadyme seed
6 grimy lantadyme
6 grimy dwarf weed

NOTE: This was with a Luck of the Dwarves on but it did not shine, so i do not think the results are skewed. I also used the same wooden recess on the NE tip every time.

Sorry if my formatting is sloppy/not as fancy as Jill's. --Zaros symbol.pngChaos Monk Talk • SignCoins 250.png 02:49, April 22, 2017 (UTC)

1080 Keys + new drop[edit source]

(hi I'm new here, please be gentle)

I did a run of 1080 keys for fun but apparently that's larger than any of the previous samples posted here, so I guess I should post the results here for posterity. I also found a Rune kiteshield (g), which means that the drop table is incomplete. I wore a Ring of Fortune doing this, but again it doesn't seem that it should skew the data. An image showing the drops (not including charms and the Black platelegs (g)) can be found here. Hope nobody minds if I copy Panjy16's formatting:

Item Total Percentage (%)
Gold charm 82 7.593
Green charm 42 3.889
Crimson charm 44 4.074
Blue charm 64 5.926
Guthix platebody 1 0.093
Rune helm 26 2.407
Rune platelegs 30 2.778
Rune spear 30 2.778
Rune pickaxe 28 2.593
Rune arrow (50) 64 5.926
Rune kiteshield (g) 1 0.093
Dragon spear 13 1.204
Grimy toadflax (2) 40 3.704
Grimy avantoe (2) 48 4.444
Grimy kwuarm (2) 45 4.167
Grimy snapdragon (2) 42 3.889
Grimy lantadyme (2) 50 4.630
Grimy dwarf weed (2) 47 4.352
Grimy torstol (2) 47 4.352
Watermelon seed (8) 52 4.815
Snape grass seed (8) 59 5.463
Lantadyme seed 30 2.778
Dwarf weed seed 25 2.315
Blood rune (20) 56 5.185
Adamantite ore (8) 59 5.463
Rune bar 27 2.500
Uncut ruby (4) 46 4.259
Uncut diamond (4) 55 5.093
Red spiders' eggs (8) 51 4.722
Limpwurt root (8) 51 4.722
Loop half of a key 24 2.222
Tooth half of a key 27 2.500
Black full helm (g) 1 0.093
Black platelegs (g) 1 0.093
Zamorak page 3 2 0.185
Zamorak page 2 1 0.093
Guthix page 2 1 0.093

Obviously, the Rune kiteshield (g) will have to be added to the drop table. I think it is reasonable to extrapolate that all the other trimmed and gilded rune armor are also part of the drop table, given that the same applies for the black and adamant armor, and because the same armor is present on the regular Columbarium key drop table. I suspect that the rarities of some of the other drops will also have to be changed due to this, but since I am not familiar with the guidelines for the different rarities used on the wiki, I will leave that to the other editors.

--Borosouro (talk) 00:45, December 19, 2017 (UTC)

Drop changes[edit source]

Seems that Clue scroll items are no longer droped?

Sample from 200 shiny keys (Vyres, Magic logs):

https://imgur.com/a/Au79myp

Friend also did 200 and got this: https://gyazo.com/09b9f2ffb51bd06eedcfc9625d8784a7

Pikka (talk) 01:15, 18 July 2020 (UTC)

Retrieved from ‘https://runescape.wiki/w/Talk:Shiny_columbarium_key?oldid=33539286’