RuneScape:The Wikian/Al Ahmed Ali (2)
Al Ahmed Ali (2)
I'm here respectly to check if I'm able to recieve "The Wikian" title already.
I've been editing the PT-BR wiki, currently I have 240 editions, including:
I'd like to recieve the title as a reward for all the effort I've been putting into the wiki. For me, it this title shows something that goes over the regular gameplay, it shows the love that I have for this game.
I'm going to respect everyones opinions, no matter what. I'm just asking you all to take a close look all my editions and if you judge me able to acheive this.
Thanks for Your attention, Al Ahmed Ali.
Account name: Al Ahmed Ali
Support - Helpful edits, constantly improving in his skills, a valuable user in overall.22:47, 13 May 2020 (UTC)
Support - Nothing personal, but the way you put it threw me off. You speak as if this was your life's work and stuff, but you "only" have 240 edits; 240 consisting of not many pages, simply because for every small change you click submit, ending up boosting your edit count by alot. That being said, apart from a few grammar errors here and there, your pages are fine and seem to be always improving in quality. Edit: changed my vote from Slight Oppose/Neutral to Support. PvM Dragonic (talk) 00:35, 19 May 2020 (UTC)
Dear, Pvm Dragonic
I appreciate your feedback, just a few comments about it:
- You said that, while talking about the ammount of my editions, That I talk as this is the work of my life.
I said that in to describe my situation. Those weren't 240 pages or 240 large editions only, and I don't believe that it must be to recieve the title. But, whenever they were short edits, I specified them. If I registered a short edition, it is because for some reason, at the time, I was unable to continue editing due to real life.
Since the day I started editing, I registered with Discord (Wiki PT-BR), that I'd be editing according to my avaliable time.
- Spelling mistakes, it was certainly not on purpose, and whenever I noticed, I corrected it.
About improving the quality of editions, thank you for registering here.
And last but not least, about a number of pages again, I really don't have many, but the ones that I do, I did from scatch or almost it, doing my best to fill the lack of content and don't leave anything behind. Those aren't random editions then.
Thanks for your vote.
Al Ahmed Ali (talk) 08:54, 20 May 2020 (UTC)
Well, the wikian requirements page says that one of the criterias is having a high number of edits, and 240 does seem to fit the bill. The main thing is that, to me, it seemed like you just boosted the edit count by clicking submit all the time just to get the title requirement and be done with it. That being said, I barely know you; we only had a few interactions on the wiki's discord, so I could very well be wrong and you legitimately care about the Wiki and gave/give your all despite whatever your current irl situation is. So, if you do care, hope that after you get the title, you keep helping the pt-br wiki grow it can stop being only a shadow of the main wiki one day. PvM Dragonic (talk) 14:42, 20 May 2020 (UTC)
Closed - Al Ahmed Ali will be granted the title.09:54, 25 May 2020 (UTC)