Humble pie is a reward for completing the Miss Schism v. Draynor Village court case. Eating this pie gives players the option of gaining experience in a skill of their choice. The amount given is one's current level in the skill multiplied by ten (). It provides half this amount for elite skills. Upon eating it, the player will be left with a pie dish in their inventory. Because it is an experience reward similar to a lamp, it cannot be banked.
- Humble pie is a reference to the phrase "to eat humble pie", which is used when someone admits an error.
- Eating the pie gives the player a message that "The pie tastes terrible, but you learn an important lesson from it."