Gnarly is a creature created by Fairy Tooth magic (implied to be grown from tooth of a terror dog) and appears in A Fairy Tale III. He first appears in a cutscene being grown by a Fairy tooth hunter and a Fairy tooth farmer. He resides in Tooth Fairy's house, and you must convince him to give you her fairy wand.
After the quest, you can obtain a tooth creature yourself by giving the Tooth fairy 5 kinds of teeth. After you have given those teeth to the fairy, she will give you a pet that looks the same as Gnarly, however this pet will be called Milk tooth creature.
The update history project is a work-in-progress – not all updates to this topic may be covered below. See here for how to help out!