Forum talk:RuneScape Model Viewer = Against the rules

From the RuneScape Wiki, the wiki for all things RuneScape
Jump to: navigation, search
This talk page is for discussing the Forum:RuneScape Model Viewer = Against the rules page.

For some reason, I can't open my editor on the original page without crashing; that's the only reason I've moved to this page. Opinion - as the Jmod at the top of the page said nothing about legal remedies, and only said that promotion of RSMV viewers, or the publication of the images will result in a player ban by Jagex, think about what that means for a minute. If Jagex catches you, the individual player, uploading or promoting, then you will be banned. You can then start up a web-site, class-action suit, and a picket line, too. In the meantime, you will not be playing RS for months, or even yearsssssss. I'll pass on that, thanks. And hiding behind the law, Mom&Dad, or RS Wiki isn't going to do you a Compost-Mound lot of good. --TheLastWordSword 16:21, February 18, 2010 (UTC)

There's no way of finding out it's you. One can assume, but unless you upload stuff with your ip here, jagex have no way of knowing. even if they can find your ip that still does not let them identify individual people, heck you could upload through a proxy if you are scared. That argument is void. Tortilliachp 15:21, February 19, 2010 (UTC)

Okay, so Jagex would have a hard time catching you if you were determined to hide your identity. But the whole point of the discussion is whether or not to upload images here, and most regular users disclose their RS names on their Userpages. It's not much fun to upload a unique image and not get credit for it. --TheLastWordSword 16:00, February 19, 2010 (UTC)

Jagex can do nothing about people who "claim" that their usernames are those on their userpages. I could claim i was Zezima, Gertjaars, 3__hit__U , Bluerose13x , Mod Andrew or Santa. Jagex cannot and will not do anything based on what you put on your user page. I wouldn't have to be determined to hide my identity, i'd have to be pretty determined on if they were to do anything. To jagex, we are all perfectly anonymous when we are other places than, as anyone can claim to be anyone they want to be online. What's with the paranoia? Tortilliachp 17:19, February 19, 2010 (UTC)

i dont think jagex will go to all that work. even if they do, it would be very easy to make it all useless. Third age robe top.png 3rd age farcaster Third age druidic robe top.png 17:30, February 19, 2010 (UTC)
Question - Okay, that all sounds pretty reasonable. So help me here...what the heck is the problem? If it's a matter of ethics alone, that makes a little sense, but if not, then what? --TheLastWordSword 18:36, February 20, 2010 (UTC)

That is what a lot of us have been asking for a very long time (as you see by the volume of the debate on the other topic, and the constant re-itteration of the same flawed argumetns). Tortilliachp 23:19, February 20, 2010 (UTC)