Forum:Yew Grove/Previously rejected proposals

From the RuneScape Wiki, the wiki for all things RuneScape
Jump to: navigation, search

This is our list of previously rejected proposals from the Yew Grove. To be included in this list:

  • The topic has been discussed and rejected at least three times.
  • The community has rejected the proposal overwhelmingly.

Wikians are not forbidden to re-raise these topics, but should note the reasons for why they failed. Such re-raised proposals must consider these objections strongly and explicitly address arguments against those objections before proposing anything similar again.

Prevent unregistered users from editing[edit source]

Use videos in the mainspace[edit source]

  • Proposal: Embed videos in the article namespace, whether it be for quest walkthroughs, combat guides, cutscenes, etc.
  • Previous discussions:
  • Reason for rejection:
    • Videos are not easily changed. MediaWiki software and the concept of wikis are built around text, not video. Requiring recording and editing software, hardware that can handle high graphics settings and video exporting, and video production skills goes against the idea of a community where "anyone can edit".
    • Due to the constantly-changing nature of RuneScape, videos may quickly become out of date.
      • If something needs to be changed, other users will not have access to the uploader's original copy of the video. Downloading the existing video, editing it, and then reuploading it will cause progressive loss in quality.
      • Certain pieces of content cannot be replayed once completed, making it difficult and/or time-consuming to create videos for them if they are updated.
    • Videos require many times more bandwidth to download than an article composed of text and images, and cannot be quickly scrolled through or searched with a browser's find function.
    • If the video is narrated, hearing-impaired users will require captions or labels to be able to understand it, at which point it is no different from reading the article.
  • Conclusion: Videos are inferior to text-based guides and should not be added by our users.