Forum:Need opinions on how to make the tables for a cleanup/expansion

From the RuneScape Wiki, the wiki for all things RuneScape
Jump to: navigation, search
Forums: Yew Grove > Need opinions on how to make the tables for a cleanup/expansion
Archive
This page or section is an archive.
Please do not edit the contents of this page.
This thread was archived on 4 July 2017 by JaydenKieran.

Hi everyone, a while ago I had set myself a goal to clean/expand every page in {{Equipment class}}

I had started on this already back then, for example at Adamant equipment, but I didn’t like that I couldn’t show the prices of the items anymore as this was incompatible with how I was formatting the tables. To solve this I have made a new template {{Equipment bonuses infotable}}, but this opens up multiple options to format those tables. So before I start again changing those pages I would like to know which format is best. I have a few options listed here so please vote on what you like most:

Weapons

w1. No price and mh/oh on one line if possible
Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonus
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant dagger.pngAdamant daggerStab384628Stab192628------
Adamant claws.pngAdamant clawsSlash384628Slash192628------
Adamant sword.pngAdamant swordStab490628Stab245628------
Adamant longsword.pngAdamant longswordSlash490628Slash245628------
Adamant scimitar.pngAdamant scimitarSlash384628Slash192628------
Adamant warhammer.pngAdamant warhammerCrush596628Crush298628------
Adamant battleaxe.pngAdamant battleaxeSlash596628Slash298628------
Adamant mace.pngAdamant maceCrush384628-----3---
Adamant off hand mace.pngAdamant off hand mace---Crush192628------
Adamant hatchet.pngAdamant hatchetSlash245628---------
Adamant 2h sword.pngAdamant 2h swordSlash894628---------
Adamant halberd.pngAdamant halberdSlash894628---------
Adamant pickaxe.pngAdamant pickaxeCrush298628---------
Adamant cane.pngAdamant caneCrush384424-----3---
Adamant hasta.pngAdamant hastaStab490628---------
Adamant defender.pngAdamant defender---Stab9662862-----
w2. No price and mh/oh on two lines
Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonus
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant dagger.pngAdamant daggerStab384628---------
Adamant off hand dagger.pngAdamant off hand dagger---Stab192628------
Adamant claws.pngAdamant clawsSlash384628---------
Adamant off hand claws.pngAdamant off hand claws---Slash192628------
Adamant sword.pngAdamant swordStab490628---------
Adamant off hand sword.pngAdamant off hand sword---Stab245628------
Adamant longsword.pngAdamant longswordSlash490628---------
Adamant off hand longsword.pngAdamant off hand longsword---Slash245628------
Adamant scimitar.pngAdamant scimitarSlash384628---------
Adamant off hand scimitar.pngAdamant off hand scimitar---Slash192628------
Adamant warhammer.pngAdamant warhammerCrush596628---------
Adamant off hand warhammer.pngAdamant off hand warhammer---Crush298628------
Adamant battleaxe.pngAdamant battleaxeSlash596628---------
Adamant off hand battleaxe.pngAdamant off hand battleaxe---Slash298628------
Adamant mace.pngAdamant maceCrush384628-----3---
Adamant off hand mace.pngAdamant off hand mace---Crush192628------
Adamant hatchet.pngAdamant hatchetSlash245628---------
Adamant 2h sword.pngAdamant 2h swordSlash894628---------
Adamant halberd.pngAdamant halberdSlash894628---------
Adamant pickaxe.pngAdamant pickaxeCrush298628---------
Adamant cane.pngAdamant caneCrush384424-----3---
Adamant hasta.pngAdamant hastaStab490628---------
Adamant defender.pngAdamant defender---Stab9662862-----
w3. With price and mh/oh on one line if possible
Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonusPrice
Main-hand
Price
Off-hand
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant dagger.pngAdamant daggerStab384628Stab192628------16,630-
Adamant claws.pngAdamant clawsSlash384628Slash192628------14,831-
Adamant sword.pngAdamant swordStab490628Stab245628------19,052-
Adamant longsword.pngAdamant longswordSlash490628Slash245628------12,224-
Adamant scimitar.pngAdamant scimitarSlash384628Slash192628------16,955-
Adamant warhammer.pngAdamant warhammerCrush596628Crush298628------18,376-
Adamant battleaxe.pngAdamant battleaxeSlash596628Slash298628------19,543-
Adamant mace.pngAdamant maceCrush384628-----3---17,710-
Adamant off hand mace.pngAdamant off hand mace---Crush192628-------9,529
Adamant hatchet.pngAdamant hatchetSlash245628---------10,017-
Adamant 2h sword.pngAdamant 2h swordSlash894628---------31,454-
Adamant halberd.pngAdamant halberdSlash894628---------15,293-
Adamant pickaxe.pngAdamant pickaxeCrush298628---------19,032-
Adamant cane.pngAdamant caneCrush384424-----3---1,239,247-
Adamant hasta.pngAdamant hastaStab490628---------9,124-
Adamant defender.pngAdamant defender---Stab9662862-------
w4. With price and mh/oh on two lines
Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonusPrice
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant dagger.pngAdamant daggerStab384628---------16,630
Adamant off hand dagger.pngAdamant off hand dagger---Stab192628------8,904
Adamant claws.pngAdamant clawsSlash384628---------14,831
Adamant off hand claws.pngAdamant off hand claws---Slash192628------8,747
Adamant sword.pngAdamant swordStab490628---------19,052
Adamant off hand sword.pngAdamant off hand sword---Stab245628------9,204
Adamant longsword.pngAdamant longswordSlash490628---------12,224
Adamant off hand longsword.pngAdamant off hand longsword---Slash245628------12,409
Adamant scimitar.pngAdamant scimitarSlash384628---------16,955
Adamant off hand scimitar.pngAdamant off hand scimitar---Slash192628------17,723
Adamant warhammer.pngAdamant warhammerCrush596628---------18,376
Adamant off hand warhammer.pngAdamant off hand warhammer---Crush298628------10,010
Adamant battleaxe.pngAdamant battleaxeSlash596628---------19,543
Adamant off hand battleaxe.pngAdamant off hand battleaxe---Slash298628------14,162
Adamant mace.pngAdamant maceCrush384628-----3---17,710
Adamant off hand mace.pngAdamant off hand mace---Crush192628------9,529
Adamant hatchet.pngAdamant hatchetSlash245628---------10,017
Adamant 2h sword.pngAdamant 2h swordSlash894628---------31,454
Adamant halberd.pngAdamant halberdSlash894628---------15,293
Adamant pickaxe.pngAdamant pickaxeCrush298628---------19,032
Adamant cane.pngAdamant caneCrush384424-----3---1,239,247
Adamant hasta.pngAdamant hastaStab490628---------9,124
Adamant defender.pngAdamant defender---Stab9662862------
w5. With price and mh/oh on two lines and price split in mh/oh
Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonusPrice
Main-hand
Price
Off-hand
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant dagger.pngAdamant daggerStab384628---------16,630-
Adamant off hand dagger.pngAdamant off hand dagger---Stab192628-------8,904
Adamant claws.pngAdamant clawsSlash384628---------14,831-
Adamant off hand claws.pngAdamant off hand claws---Slash192628-------8,747
Adamant sword.pngAdamant swordStab490628---------19,052-
Adamant off hand sword.pngAdamant off hand sword---Stab245628-------9,204
Adamant longsword.pngAdamant longswordSlash490628---------12,224-
Adamant off hand longsword.pngAdamant off hand longsword---Slash245628-------12,409
Adamant scimitar.pngAdamant scimitarSlash384628---------16,955-
Adamant off hand scimitar.pngAdamant off hand scimitar---Slash192628-------17,723
Adamant warhammer.pngAdamant warhammerCrush596628---------18,376-
Adamant off hand warhammer.pngAdamant off hand warhammer---Crush298628-------10,010
Adamant battleaxe.pngAdamant battleaxeSlash596628---------19,543-
Adamant off hand battleaxe.pngAdamant off hand battleaxe---Slash298628-------14,162
Adamant mace.pngAdamant maceCrush384628-----3---17,710-
Adamant off hand mace.pngAdamant off hand mace---Crush192628-------9,529
Adamant hatchet.pngAdamant hatchetSlash245628---------10,017-
Adamant 2h sword.pngAdamant 2h swordSlash894628---------31,454-
Adamant halberd.pngAdamant halberdSlash894628---------15,293-
Adamant pickaxe.pngAdamant pickaxeCrush298628---------19,032-
Adamant cane.pngAdamant caneCrush384424-----3---1,239,247-
Adamant hasta.pngAdamant hastaStab490628---------9,124-
Adamant defender.pngAdamant defender---Stab9662862-------
w6. With price and mh/oh seperated in two tables [1]

Main hand weapons

Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonusPrice
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant dagger.pngAdamant daggerStab384628---------16,630
Adamant claws.pngAdamant clawsSlash384628---------14,831
Adamant sword.pngAdamant swordStab490628---------19,052
Adamant longsword.pngAdamant longswordSlash490628---------12,224
Adamant scimitar.pngAdamant scimitarSlash384628---------16,955
Adamant warhammer.pngAdamant warhammerCrush596628---------18,376
Adamant battleaxe.pngAdamant battleaxeSlash596628---------19,543
Adamant mace.pngAdamant maceCrush384628-----3---17,710
Adamant hatchet.pngAdamant hatchetSlash245628---------10,017
Adamant pickaxe.pngAdamant pickaxeCrush298628---------19,032
Adamant cane.pngAdamant caneCrush384424-----3---1,239,247
Adamant hasta.pngAdamant hastaStab490628---------9,124

Off-hand weapons

Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonusPrice
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant off hand dagger.pngAdamant off hand dagger---Stab192628------8,904
Adamant off hand claws.pngAdamant off hand claws---Slash192628------8,747
Adamant off hand sword.pngAdamant off hand sword---Stab245628------9,204
Adamant off hand longsword.pngAdamant off hand longsword---Slash245628------12,409
Adamant off hand scimitar.pngAdamant off hand scimitar---Slash192628------17,723
Adamant off hand warhammer.pngAdamant off hand warhammer---Crush298628------10,010
Adamant off hand battleaxe.pngAdamant off hand battleaxe---Slash298628------14,162
Adamant off hand mace.pngAdamant off hand mace---Crush192628------9,529
Adamant defender.pngAdamant defender---Stab9662862------

Two-handed weapons

Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonusPrice
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant 2h sword.pngAdamant 2h swordSlash894628---------31,454
Adamant halberd.pngAdamant halberdSlash894628---------15,293
  1. ^ Suggested by Aescopalus, added on 21:24, June 27, 2017 (UTC)

Personally I like w3 the most because it is more compact. Invention.pngCephHunter talkSlayer.png 17:30, June 27, 2017 (UTC)

Armour

a1. Weapon stats remain and no price
Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonus
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant full helm.pngAdamant full helm------125-----
Adamant med helm.pngAdamant med helm------118-----
Adamant platebody.pngAdamant platebody------144-----
Adamant chainbody.pngAdamant chainbody------135-----
Adamant kiteshield.pngAdamant kiteshield------125-----
Adamant square shield.pngAdamant square shield------118-----
Adamant berserker shield.pngAdamant berserker shield------146-----
Adamant spikeshield.pngAdamant spikeshield------137-----
Adamant platelegs.pngAdamant platelegs------138-----
Adamant plateskirt.pngAdamant plateskirt------138-----
Adamant gauntlets.pngAdamant gauntlets------31-----
Culinaromancer's gloves 7.pngAdamant gloves------19--555
Adamant armoured boots.pngAdamant armoured boots------31-----
a2. Weapon stats are hidden and no price
Attack.png
Item
AttributeStyle bonus
DefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant full helm.pngAdamant full helm125-----
Adamant med helm.pngAdamant med helm118-----
Adamant platebody.pngAdamant platebody144-----
Adamant chainbody.pngAdamant chainbody135-----
Adamant kiteshield.pngAdamant kiteshield125-----
Adamant square shield.pngAdamant square shield118-----
Adamant berserker shield.pngAdamant berserker shield146-----
Adamant spikeshield.pngAdamant spikeshield137-----
Adamant platelegs.pngAdamant platelegs138-----
Adamant plateskirt.pngAdamant plateskirt138-----
Adamant gauntlets.pngAdamant gauntlets31-----
Culinaromancer's gloves 7.pngAdamant gloves19--555
Adamant armoured boots.pngAdamant armoured boots31-----
a3. Weapon stats remain with price
Attack.png
Item
Main-handOff-handAttributeStyle bonusPrice
StyleDmgAccStyleDmgAccDefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant full helm.pngAdamant full helm------125-----6,073
Adamant med helm.pngAdamant med helm------118-----12,710
Adamant platebody.pngAdamant platebody------144-----20,703
Adamant chainbody.pngAdamant chainbody------135-----20,858
Adamant kiteshield.pngAdamant kiteshield------125-----21,630
Adamant square shield.pngAdamant square shield------118-----17,812
Adamant berserker shield.pngAdamant berserker shield------146-----Fist of Guthix token.png 100
Adamant spikeshield.pngAdamant spikeshield------137-----Fist of Guthix token.png 50
Adamant platelegs.pngAdamant platelegs------138-----15,062
Adamant plateskirt.pngAdamant plateskirt------138-----11,619
Adamant gauntlets.pngAdamant gauntlets------31-----1,740
Culinaromancer's gloves 7.pngAdamant gloves------19--5552,500
Adamant armoured boots.pngAdamant armoured boots------31-----5,693
a4. Weapon stats are hidden with price
Attack.png
Item
AttributeStyle bonusPrice
DefenceConstitutionPrayerAttack-icon.pngRanged-icon.pngMagic-icon.png
Adamant full helm.pngAdamant full helm125-----6,073
Adamant med helm.pngAdamant med helm118-----12,710
Adamant platebody.pngAdamant platebody144-----20,703
Adamant chainbody.pngAdamant chainbody135-----20,858
Adamant kiteshield.pngAdamant kiteshield125-----21,630
Adamant square shield.pngAdamant square shield118-----17,812
Adamant berserker shield.pngAdamant berserker shield146-----Fist of Guthix token.png 100
Adamant spikeshield.pngAdamant spikeshield137-----Fist of Guthix token.png 50
Adamant platelegs.pngAdamant platelegs138-----15,062
Adamant plateskirt.pngAdamant plateskirt138-----11,619
Adamant gauntlets.pngAdamant gauntlets31-----1,740
Culinaromancer's gloves 7.pngAdamant gloves19--5552,500
Adamant armoured boots.pngAdamant armoured boots31-----5,693

Here I like a4 the most. Invention.pngCephHunter talkSlayer.png 17:30, June 27, 2017 (UTC)

Discussion

Support a4 and modified w4 - These look good - a compact way to present all relevant information. I think having three weapons tables - one for off-hand, one for main-hand, one for two-handed - would look best, as opposed to putting all into one table. These could still be grouped into a subsection on the relevant page. This would not affect the template design, just its usage Smithing.pngAescopalus talkCrafting.png 17:46, June 27, 2017 (UTC)

w4 or 6, a3 or 4 - Keeping the main and off-hands split keeps the information the clearest about what item gives what stats. I don't see why armour can't show price, but I'm not sure on hiding weapon stats.

Can I also suggest, as part of these changes, creating a category for these pages - equipment in a set or theme, including weapon-only sets (drygore weaponry), armour-only sets (torva equipment), and mixed sets (rune equipment). Say, Category:Equipment sets. Category:Item sets should be only Grand Exchange sets so should have incorrectly categorised pages removed. Quest.png Gaz Lloyd 7:^]Events!99s 16:49, June 28, 2017 (UTC)

Sure i can do that as well, but wouldn't it be better to keep Category:Item sets for all sets and make a new Category:Grand Exchange sets for Grand Exchange sets because Item sets doesn't really imply that it is for GE sets only. Invention.pngCephHunter talkSlayer.png 16:17, June 29, 2017 (UTC)

w3, a3 Compact but each give all the information. Also may I just add that I find general info pages for equipment sets, rather than the mere disambigs that some sets have and having to look on each individual page, way more useful. Thanks for taking the time to expand them. -- Cycloneblaze (user - talk - contribs) 17:40, June 28, 2017 (UTC)

w6, a4 In w6, splitting the weapons into main- and off-hand makes for a cleaner look and is easier to read. Also, armour iirc doesn't give weapon bonuses, just the style bonuses, so that's why a4./bren/tc 04:36, June 30, 2017 (UTC)

w6, a4 - Per Bren. Farming-icon.png Salix of Prifddinas (Talk) Prifddinas lodestone icon.png 13:58, June 30, 2017 (UTC)

Closed - a4 and w6 seem to be the consensus here. In regards to creating a category as added by Gaz, feel free to use your own judgement for that as it isn't really a big deal. jayden 17:51, July 4, 2017 (UTC)